mystic beanie baby on eBay US
Want instant alerts when new items are listed? Create a free account to set up real-time search alerts.
Original Ty Beanie Baby Mystic Unicorn 1994
$10.99
Used
Ty Vintage 1993 1994 Beanie Baby Mystic, the Unicorn, Plush Toy; with Tag.
$7.00
Used
Ty Beanie Baby Mystic Unicorn White Iridescent Horn Yarn Mane 1993 1994
$15.00
Used
Ty Beanie Baby Mystic The Unicorn TAG ERROR 1993/1994 PVC Pellets
$9.99
New
Ty Beanie Baby Mystic Unicorn Error 1993 1994 Tags Ear Tag Plastic Case Rare
$12.00
Used
Ty Beanie Baby Mystic The Unicorn 1993 Iridescent Horn White Plush Animal
$12.86
Used
Mystic The Unicorn Ty Beanie Babies Lot (3) - Brown, Irradescent, Fine, PVC, Err
$150.00
Used
❤️ Ty® Beanie Baby ❤️ Mystic ❤️ The Unicorn New Mint w/Tag Protector
$2.99
New
TY Beanie Babies Mystic & Scorch Fantasy Lot 2 Unicorn Dragon
$24.99
Used
Ty Beanie Babies Mystic Unicorn Plush 1993, Recommended Age 3+, Ages 4-11 Years
$4.00
Used
Ty Beanie Babies Mystic The Unicorn - 04007
$3.99
Used
Ty Beanie Baby Mystic Unicorn Gold Horn DOB 5/21/94 with Club Card & Clear Case.
$19.99
Used
Ty Beanie Baby Mystic Unicorn Plush Retired Original 1994 Blue Eyes
$9.48
New
Vintage 1993 Ty Beanie Baby Mystic The Unicorn Horn Rainbow Color Plush Toy
$10.80
New
TY Beanie Buddy Mystic Unicorn Plush White Rainbow Mane Mythical Stuffed Toy
$22.00
Used
beanie babies rare Mystic tag cover
$400.00
Used
Set of 2 Ty Beanie Babies: PEGASUS (Winged Horse) & MYSTIC (Unicorn) Plush **NEW
$12.99
New
Ty Beanie Babies Mystic The Unicorn - 04007
$9.99
New
Ty Beanie Baby MYSTIC UNICORN Metallic 5th Gen 1993 PVC Pellets TRUSTED SELLER
$19.99
New
TY Beanie Baby Mystic Unicorn White with Tag Protector Blue Eyes Plush 90s
$21.99
Used
TY Beanie Baby, "Mystic" with Iridescent Horn
$5.00
Used
TY Beanie Baby 1994 Mystic the UNICORN Plush Toy RARE Tan Horn Retired 4th Gen
$28.99
New
Mystic the Unicorn (Rare) TY Beanie Baby.Rainbow Maine& Iridescent Horn.
$26.85
Used
Ty Beanie Babies Mystic The Unicorn Fine Yarn Mane Tan Horn 3rd/1st Generation
$24.99
Used
TY Beanie Baby 3 Beanie Babies: 2 Horses (Derby) & 1 Unicorn (Mystic)
$17.39
Used
Ty Beanie Baby Mystic the Unicorn (Retired) 4th Generation DOB 5-21-94
$11.90
New
TY Beanie Babies Lot of 18 Retired Mystic Pouch Ants Goochy No Hang Tags on Most
$70.00
Used
Lot of 4 Vintage Ty Beanie Babies PVC Pellets Derby Mystic Spinner Doodle W/Tags
$25.00
Used
TY Beanie Baby “Mystic” The Unicorn Ty 1993-94 Tag Vintage Retired
$27.64
Used
Ty Beanie Babies Mystic The Unicorn - 04007
$10.00
New
Ty Beanie Babies Mystic The White Unicorn Pink Horn Plush Toy 8" 1993
$6.30
Used
Ty Beanie Babies Mystic The Unicorn Plush Stuffed Animal 1993 RETIRED
$6.30
Used
Ty Beanie Babies 1993 8 Inch Mystic The White Unicorn Pink Horn Plush Toy
$6.30
Used
Ty Original Beanie Baby mystic 1994 Unicorn MINT CONDITION
$25.00
New
Ty Beanie Babies Mystic The Unicorn Beanbag Plush Stuffed Animal Toy 1993
$6.30
Used
Ty Beanie Babies Mystic Unicorn Retired Original White Plush 1994
$250.00
Used
Vintage 1994 TY Beanie Babies “Mystic” The Unicorn W/ GOLD HORN & Tag READ
$20.49
Used
'Mystical Mermaid' Baby Beanie Hat (BH00031548)
$20.21
New with tags
'Mystical Chalice' Baby Beanie Hat (BH00028499)
$20.21
New with tags
VINTAGE Ty Beanie Baby 1994 Mystic THE HORSE (Tush Tag Dated 1993)
$12.98
Used
Ty Beanie Baby Mystic Unicorn White 1994 Retired Original with Tag
$20.00
Used
Ty Beanie Babies Lot Of 3 Mystic The Unicorn 3 Variations All With Tags Mint (9)
$22.45
New
RARE RETIRED Ty Beanie Babies Mystic The Unicorn 93/94 (Tan Horn) PVC 4007 W Tag
$99.99
New
Ty Beanie Babies Mystic The Unicorn - 04007
$29.99
New
1993 Ty ORIGINAL BEANIE BABY Babies Collection Mystic Unicorn Iridescent Horn
$10.19
New
TY Mystic The Unicorn Rare /Retired, 1994 Mint Condition
$400.00
New
Ty Beanie Baby Mystic The Unicorn TAG ERROR 1993/1994 PVC Pellets
$12.00
New
Vintage 1993 Ty Beanie Babies Mystic The Unicorn- RETIRED
$12.95
Used
Market Insights
Average Price
$41.88
Price Range
$2.99–$400.00
Total Listings
4054
Top Conditions
- NEW1924
- USED2135
- UNSPECIFIED4